Profile:
dentedskull

This is your Profile page. Use it to check replies to your comments, keep track of comments you've made or endorsed, and manage your regulation room account.

Watch a Video: Understanding Your Profile Page [0:38]

What's Happening Now

July 21, 2010 11:19 pm

Charging extra for all checked bags ultimately causes passenger injuries. It’s a safety issue.

The proposed rule is wise and good and forbids a despicable practice, but misses the larger issue of passenger safety. Charging a fee for all checked baggage is the problem that you should focus on.

Charging for all checked bags encourages travelers to overload the overhead bins with large, heavy bags. Passengers are not professional baggage handlers. Baggage handlers don’t hoist bags they can barely lift over passengers’ heads. Passengers do this or pay $20-$40 extra per bag. Passengers are not as fit as baggage handlers, are not trained at all, and often can not lift their bags into the crowded overhead bins. Many need wheels to move their “carry on” bags through the airport. Passengers frequently drop bags on other passengers while loading or unloading the bins, and the overloaded bins occasionally pop open and dump during the flight.

These large bags, especially the wheels, hurt when a bag falls on your head. I’ve only gotten one cut and one ringer so far, both since the baggage fee brutality came in. I witness one accident every third flight.

Please require airlines to allow for some generous weight in checked baggage. Let it be part of the ticket. The old limit of 75 pounds domestic was really nice, but even 30 pounds would be more than plenty.

The passengers hate the baggage charge for many reasons. It’s not just the sleazy entrapment the proposed rule addresses. It is a safety issue and should be regulated as such. Fix the root problem.

August 10, 2010 10:46 pm

Jessmoanikeala, would it be fair if domestic travelers weren’t charged extra for checked bags (no fees, the way it was two years ago)?

August 10, 2010 10:51 pm

And then there’s the effect of all the extra carry-ons on the cabin crew: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704388504575419743157731062.html .

August 17, 2010 10:07 pm

http://www.airfarewatchdog.com/blog/3801089/airline-baggage-fees-chart-updated/ lists fees for major airlines. They all seem to settle into the $15-$35 each way.

The airlines aren’t competing on price for checked baggage. I think the best solution is $0.